Emergency Board No. 129, Long Island Railroad and the Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen,
Locals 517 and 1090, Records, 1960
Collection Number: 5102
Kheel Center for Labor-Management Documentation & Archives
Cornell University Library
DESCRIPTIVE SUMMARY
Title:
Emergency Board No. 129, Long Island Railroad and the Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen,
Locals 517 and 1090, Records, 1960
Repository:
Kheel Center for Labor-Management Documentation & Archives
Collection Number:
5102
Abstract:
Documents include reports, recommendations and proposals of the Emergency Board and
of the New York State Board of Inquiry; proposals of the carrier, union and National
Mediation Board; carrier and union exhibits, statements and agreements.
Creator:
Emergency Board No. 129
Long Island Railroad
Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen. Local 517
Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen. Local 1090
Quanitities:
0.5 cubic feet
Language:
Collection material in English
On April 19, 1960, the President of the U. S., acting under the authority given to
him by the Railway Labor Act, created an Emergency Board to investigate and report
on the dispute between the Long Island Rail Road and the Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen
Locals 517 and 1090. The members of the Board were Curtis G. Shake, Chairman, Lloyd
H. Bailer, and Edward A. Lynch.
The union's demands on the Long Island Rail Road which brought about the dispute
were:
1. Reduction of the six-day week to five days for passenger service trainmen, without
a reduction in pay.
2. Reduction of the work week for all men in local freight service to five days a
week without loss of pay. The company contended that conductors and brakemen were
required seven days a week.
3. Payment of switchtenders at the higher brakemen's rate.
4. Payment of the 95 cent daily allowance to yard trainmen not required to handle
air hose for handling air hose.
On May 18, 1960, the Emergency Board found that rates being paid to Long Island trainmen
were higher than the standard rates on other Class I carriers. Average annual earnings
for Long Island trainmen were $7,965 in 1959 compared with $7,263 on all other Class
I carriers.
The Railroad Trainmen then served an official notice on the Long Island Rail Road
that they would go on strike at 12:01 A.M., Sunday, June 19.
Two days before the strike was scheduled to begin, W. P. Kennedy, International President
of the Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen, ordered locals 517 and 1090 to postpone the
strike on an appeal by the National Mediation Board for a resumption of conferences
"in the public interest."
Efforts of the National Mediation Board to avert the strike collapsed one week later,
which released the trainmen from their no strike pledge and a strike was tentatively
set for Sunday, July 10 at 12:01 am. After authorization received from International
President Kennedy, July 10 was confirmed as the strike date.
On July 6, Governor Rockefeller took personal charge of efforts to prevent a strike
on the Long Island Rail Road. He sent telegrams to company and union executives asking
them to meet with George Moskowitz, Chairman of the State Mediation Board. Governor
Rockefeller stepped in only after the union had rejected a plea by city, state and
county officials for a two week postponement of the strike.
The Governor was able to persuade the railroad to accept a five day work week, but
only with the stipulation that the union agree to moves which would help keep the
costs at a minimum. The union refused to accept any economy moves and the conference
ended without success.
The strike began, as scheduled, on Sunday morning, July 10. The State Public Service
Commission immediately authorized all bus companies in Nassau and Suffolk counties
and in Manhattan, Brooklyn and Queens to provide all possible transportation to the
strike affected area. The Transport Workers Union supported the trainmen, refusing
to work overtime and by not working on extra buses or subway trains in Queens or Long
Island.
Industrial Commissioner Martin P. Catherwood then appointed a State Board of Inquiry
consisting of the Very Rev. Philip E. Dobson of Fordham University, Peter J. Keulemans
of General Bronze Co., and Dean John W. McConnell of Industrial and Labor Relations
School at Cornell University. The board was directed to study all factors necessary
to guarantee safe and efficient commuter service "with benefit to the economy of the
area and at prices the commuting public can afford," and to make recommendations to
help end the strike.
The Board of Inquiry proposed an arbitration plan on July 14 which called for a five
day week with no cut in pay for the trainmen. Also included was a provision which
would leave to final and binding arbitration the issue of how the shorter work week
would be paid for. The union refused to accept binding arbitration.
On July 20 the National Mediation Board proposed a plan whereby the BRT would agree
to a 2 1/2 cent-an-hour wage cut to help pay for the increased cost of a five day
week. This proposal was accepted by the union but the railroad rejected it saying
that the increased costs would still necessitate higher fares for passengers. The
company again suggested binding arbitration on the method of financing the shorter
work week, but the union still refused.
On August 3, 1960, Governor Rockefeller called the disputing parties together for
a conference which lasted eleven and one-half hours before an agreement was reached.
The three year agreement guaranteed a five day week. The cost of the shortened work
week was set at $357,592, of which the company agreed to pay $162,041. The trainmen
absorbed the remainder of the cost by agreeing to a 2 1/2 cent-an-hour wage cut and
changes in work rules enabling more complete utilization of the existing work force.
The union withdrew its demand for a five day week in freight service in return for
a total of $53,040 in added compensation. The union won agreement to its other two
demands. Yard service men will receive 95 cents per day for coupling air hose and
switchtenders will receive extra pay when performing brakemen's duties.
Emergency Board documents include carrier exhibits concerning the demands of the parties
and the applicable rules of the existing agreement; and statements by officers of
the Long Island Railroad. Union exhibits include local agreements (1953-1957) between
the Long Island Railroad Company and road and yard conductors, ticket collectors,
road and yard brakemen and switchtenders; and related Trainmen's publications.
Additional materials include transcripts of hearings (8 vol.); report to the president;
order establishing the New York State Board of Inquiry; interim report (with draft)
and recommendations of the Board of Inquiry; mediation agreements (1957, 1960) between
railroads represented by the Eastern, Western, and Southeastern Carriers' Conference
Committees and the Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen; also proposals of the union,
carriers, and the National Mediation Board.
Access to the collections in the Kheel Center is restricted. Please contact a reference
archivist for access to these materials.
This collection must be used in keeping with the Kheel Center Information Sheet and
Procedures for Document Use.
INFORMATION FOR USERS
Emergency Board No. 129, Long Island Railroad and the Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen,
Locals 517 and 1090, Records #5102. Kheel Center for Labor-Management Documentation
and Archives, Cornell University Library.
Related Collections: 5021: Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen Additional Records 5149: Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen Records 5149 MB: Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen Memorabilia 5149 P: Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen Photographs 5348: W.P. Kennedy as President of the Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen against the
Long Island Railroad Company Court Documents 5446: Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen Ledger 5612: Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen Moosic Tunnel Lodge no.93 Meeting Minutes 5623: Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen Legislative Board of New York Files 5631: Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen Chicago, Milwaukee, St. Paul and Pacific Railroad
General Committee File 5647: Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen Joppa Lodge (Toledo, OH) Minute Books 5894: Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen Additional Railroad Booklets 6268 P: Joint Committee of Adjustment for the Rock Island System's Order of Railway
Conductors and Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen Photograph 6312 P: Judith Sullivan Kowalczyk Collection of Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen
Photographs 6312 PUBS: Judith Sullivan Kowalczyk Collection of Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen
Publications 6312m: Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen Annual Report of the Legislative Board 6405 PUBS: William Sharp Collection of The Railroad Trainmen's Journal 6480 MB: Paul Berger Collection of Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen Memorabilia
Names:
Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen
Eastern Carriers' Conference Committee
Long Island Railroad Company
Southeastern Carriers' Conference Committee
United States. Emergency Board No. 129.
United States. National Mediation Board.
Western Carriers' Conference Committee
United States.
Subjects:
Mediation and conciliation, Industrial--New York (State)--Cases.
Mediation and conciliation, Industrial--United States--Cases.
Railroad employees.
Railroad trainmen.
Collective labor agreements. Railroads. New York (State)
Hours of labor. Mediation and conciliation, Industrial. United States.
Management rights. Mediation and conciliation, Industrial. United States.
Mediation and conciliation, Industrial. Railroads. United States.
Railroads. New York (State). State supervision.
Wages. Mediation and conciliation, Industrial. United States.
Wages. Railroads. New York (State)
Work rules. Mediation and conciliation, Industrial. United States.
CONTAINER LIST
Container
|
Description
|
Date
|
|
Box 1 | Folder 1 |
Reports and exhibits [folder 1 of 2]
|
1960 |
Box 1 | Folder 2 |
Reports and exhibits [folder 2 of 2]
|
1960 |
Box 1 | Folder 3 |
John W. McConnell's notes
|
1960 |