In May of 1867, White contacted Frederick Law Olmsted, who had been interested in
campus planning for some time, to consult about the appearance of the new campus. Olmsted
recommended abandoning the quadrangle idea, urging a freer disposition of the buildings
more in keeping with the rugged topography of the site and the unforeseeable demands of
later generations. The recommendation came too late; planning was well advanced and White
was committed to the quadrangle design. Nonetheless, Olmsted was at least able to
reconcile the divergent approaches of White and Ezra Cornell. Olmsted's comments and plans
deserve much of the credit for the quality of Cornells Arts Quadrangle. The
site of your second building having been determined against my judgment, it seems to me to
be very important that nothing should be done which shall make the suggestion which I
offered to you in regard to a terrace impracticable and especially if the first building
is duplicated, that its roof lines and base lines should be on the same level with those
of the first.
If it is to be almost a duplicate, it should be precisely a duplicate otherwise
(especially with a difference of two feet elevation on the horizontal sky-lines), it will
look as if any variation has been accidental and a mistake arising from the carelessness
or stupidity of the builders. I am surprised to think that Mr. Cornell would entertain
such a project; the expense to be saved by it is very trifling. |